you order.
we bake.
orders close in
sun, nov 1 at 11:59pm · pickup fri, nov 6 & sat, nov 7
upcoming drops
why the week in between? shop, prep & bake days. we buy exactly what's ordered and bake it fresh for that week, so nothing sits and nothing goes to waste.
Frequently Asked Questions
-
fresh-baked cookies and cupcakes, made in small drops, plus catering for bigger events. cookies come in boxes of 4, 8, 12 or 36, and each cookie is individually wrapped and labeled. cupcakes come in labeled containers of 12 or 24. everything is baked after you order, and pickup only, in bergen county, nj.
-
a drop is a short window when orders are open. we bake new flavors with every drop, and classics are always on the menu. when the window closes, we shop, prep and bake fresh just for the orders we received, so nothing sits and nothing goes to waste.
-
we bake in drops, so you order while a drop is open. choose your box, pick your flavors, then choose a pickup day and time at checkout. after the window closes, we shop, prep and bake fresh, then you pick up in bergen county. the current drop and its dates are always shown at the top of our home page and order page.
-
that week is our shop, prep and bake week. we buy exactly what’s been ordered and bake it fresh, so every box is made for you, not made ahead and left on a shelf.
-
pickup only, in bergen county, nj. we don’t offer delivery. each drop has a friday and a saturday pickup option, and you choose your day and time at checkout. your exact address and pickup window are in your confirmation email.
-
absolutely. our celebration Box is available for events requiring 50 or more cookies, while custom cupcake orders begin at 36 cupcakes. complete our inquiry form and we'll create a custom proposal based on your event, guest count, and flavor preferences.
-
at buttr. nuts are NOT used as ingredients in any of our recipes. we don’t use nuts in our recipes to help prevent cross-contamination. but we are a home kitchen that also houses nuts, and our ingredients are made in facilities that process nuts, so we can’t guarantee anything is nut-free. if you have an allergy, please use your own judgment and be careful before eating.
-
food safety and quality are at the heart of everything we do. buttr. operates in accordance with New Jersey Cottage Food regulations and maintains current food safety certifications, including a ServSafe Food Protection Manager Certification, the highest level of ServSafe food safety training. every product is prepared with careful attention to cleanliness, consistency, and quality.
-
small batch doesn't mean small standards. all buttr. ingredients, equipment, and baking supplies are maintained separately from household items, including dedicated refrigerator and freezer storage. our bowls, utensils, scales, and production equipment are reserved exclusively for buttr. baking to help ensure consistency, cleanliness, and quality in every batch. we take every reasonable precaution to minimize cross-contact while operating within a home kitchen environment.
-
For catering orders only, custom packaging options are available for an additional cost. If you're interested in please include those additional details in your inquiry form.
-
boxes are priced by size, and the bigger the box, the less each cookie costs. you’ll find current prices on the order page. catering starts at 50 cookies, see the catering page for pricing.
-
life happens! because every order is baked fresh just for you, you can get a full refund up to 48 hours before your pickup time. after that, we’ve already shopped and baked, so we can’t offer refunds. need to change something or have a problem with your order? text us anytime at (862) 388-5420.